[Air-l] Re: first post (An Internet Without Space)

[Rhiannon Bury]

I too enjoyed Don's thought-provoking post and wholeheartedly agree with 
the main point that we can't just come up with theories about 
"cyberspace" with no context of use (1990s "cyberbabble", heheh, I've 
have to remember that one).

That said, I'm uncomfortable what seems to be the resurrection of the 
old theory/practice binary. Like Lori and Radhika, I do ethnographic 
work, but I'm also a  poststructuralist.  I certainly understand Don's 
concerns about imposing "northern strands" (I think those were his 
words) of theories in non-western contexts. But, what is the 
alternative? Taking participants'  experiences and accounts as 
unadulterated "truth" that we have "discovered" through our research? 
Our own stories and that includes our theories, are always part of the 
frame. As Deborah Britzman say, ethnographic accounts are "overinvested 
in second hand memories." As I mentioned earlier in the thread, I use 
Foucault's conceptualization of the heterotopia.  It was my data that 
led to me to work with this notion, not the other way around. Yet, the 
participants would not necessarily describe their "spaces" as 
heterotopic and might think it's just a bunch of academic whooey for all 
I know (but just be too polite to say so.)


Rhiannon

radhika_gajjala wrote:

> ditto.
>
> (I may even take this rant to my research methods class;-))
>
> r
>
> At 2:44 PM -0500 2/11/04, Kendall, Lori wrote:
>
>> Woo! I greatly enjoyed Don Slater's post on this issue and 
>> particularly the
>> rant about ethnography.  (No big surprise to anyone who knows me, I'm 
>> sure!)
>>
>> Lori
>> ________________________________________
>> Lori Kendall
>> Assistant Professor of Sociology
>> Purchase College-SUNY
>> lori.kendall at purchase.edu
>>
>> _______________________________________________
>> Air-l mailing list
>> Air-l at aoir.org
>> http://www.aoir.org/mailman/listinfo/air-l
>
>
>
>
> _______________________________________________
> Air-l mailing list
> Air-l at aoir.org
> http://www.aoir.org/mailman/listinfo/air-l
>