[Air-l] Christians against MySpace?
Ellis Godard
ellis.godard at csun.edu
Thu Mar 30 10:33:16 PST 2006
The ludicrousness is multi-dimensional. MySpace is non-unique, immediately
replaceable, and part of a much larger (and uncontrollable) medium.
If Vietti wants separation from communication used by others in ways that
may tempt still others towards potential damnation, maybe Osama's got space
in his cave.
For that matter (and speaking of Osama), I'll wager that religion (even
Christianity) has been associated with more murders than MySpace has been
associated with sexual predation - in which case Vietti should urge teens to
swear off church.
Preaching to the choir,
Ellis
> -----Original Message-----
> From: air-l-bounces at listserv.aoir.org
> [mailto:air-l-bounces at listserv.aoir.org] On Behalf Of danah boyd
> Sent: Wednesday, March 29, 2006 12:51 PM
> To: air-l at listserv.aoir.org
> Subject: Re: [Air-l] Christians against MySpace?
>
>
> Pastors are speaking out against MySpace during their services.
> (I've copied an article below to give the sentiments - it seems to
> have been taken offline.) That said, there are huge Christian
> contingents on MySpace, including many religious teens who share
> Christian rock music and discuss bible studies in their profiles.
> Other social networking sites are popping up and attracting
> religious
> teens, including YFly.com.
>
>
> Pastor airs problem with MySpace.com
>
> Valley Bible Fellowship leader warns parents against online
> forum popular with kids, teens
>
> By DAVID BURGER, Californian staff writer
> e-mail: dburger at bakersfield.com
>
> Posted: Sunday February 12th, 2006, 10:20 PM
> Last Updated: Monday February 13th, 2006, 9:19 AM
>
> Is MySpace.com just another front for, say, MySatan.com?
>
> That’s the view of Ron Vietti, senior pastor of Valley Bible
> Fellowship in east Bakersfield. Vietti used Sunday’s three services
> to deliver an hourlong attack against the evils of Internet social
> Web site MySpace.com and how it is “worse than crack, cocaine or
> meth.” The senior pastor said the popular Web site lures young boys
> into pornography and sets up young girls as victims of sexual
> predators.
>
> “You say I’m mad — you bet I’m mad!” he said to the capacity crowd
> during the 11:30 a.m. service, as congregants in the crowd hollered
> “Amens” and “Yeahs.”
>
> MySpace.com, according to The Associated Press, has two-and-a-half
> times the traffic of Google.com, with over 50 million users
> according
> to some estimates. The free site — which uses advertising to make
> money — allows people to create personal Web pages to talk to
> friends, write their own blogs or meet new friends.
>
> The “new friends” are what Vietti is worried about. With six large
> binders in his hand, full of salacious pictures he printed off of
> MySpace.com — pictures primarily of young girls — the pastor told
> parents to get more involved in overseeing what Junior is doing in
> his bedroom online.
>
> “Pornography is a growing problem that is sweeping our land,” Vietti
> said.
>
> “(The Internet) is one-stop shopping for sexual predators,” he later
> said.
>
> Vietti spent between 36 and 38 hours on MySpace.com this past week,
> after never hearing of the site until just a month ago. One
> night, he
> was up from 10 p.m. to 6 a.m. documenting the evil he saw displayed.
>
> The Web site allows people to post pictures and messages of whatever
> they’d like, Vietti said. Many times this involves pornographic
> material, the pastor claimed.
>
> Vietti’s remarks contrast with the written MySpace.com photo
> submission policy. According to rules posted on the Web site,
> MySpace
> users must be at least 14 years old, and submitted photos must not
> contain any sexually explicit imagery, including nudity or
> pornography.
>
> The policy also tells members that offensive photos can be flagged
> and removed by site administrators.
>
> Vietti told his congregation of his own history: when he was 13, he
> became addicted to pornography and wasn’t unleashed until he entered
> his 20s and “gave my life to God.”
>
> At the beginning of the service, the congregants — there are 8,000
> members of the church, Vietti said — received a card titled
> “Commitment to Higher Values.”
>
> The card implored parents to commit to four things: putting a filter
> on the Internet; putting the family computer in an open area;
> locking
> out the computer when parents aren’t home; and spending more time
> with their children.
>
> Vietti didn’t stop there. At 6 p.m. on Feb. 20, he wants people
> concerned about stamping out Internet pornography to join a group he
> calls “Special Ops Ministry” at the church building. The group will
> go to places, like bars, where young people hang out to
> convince them
> to delete MySpace.com from their computers and lives.
>
> Congregants and fellow ministers were motivated by the pastor’s
> impassioned testimony, they said.
>
> Youth pastor Vince Sierra, 24, said that although MySpace.com does
> some good by helping people meet one another, the cons outweigh the
> pros.
>
> “I call it ‘My Waste of Space.com,’” said the pastor, who ministers
> to 200 students in high school and 350 students in junior high. “I
> think it’s a place where kids waste their time and lose that social
> touch.”
>
> “I don’t (use the Internet) at home, because I don’t trust myself,”
> said Vietti’s 25-year-old son Josh. The temptation to look at
> indecent pictures
> would be too strong if he used the computer at home, he said.
>
> Teenagers who are members of both the church and MySpace.com said
> they’ve now given up the latter after hearing their pastor.
>
> Richard Fuentez, 16, a junior at Golden Valley High School,
> said that
> although all of his friends are on MySpace, he is going to
> stop using
> it.
>
> “I’d be a hypocrite if I kept it,” he said. He said, until
> Sunday, he
> didn’t know that young girls who posted pictures and personal
> information of themselves on the site were unwillingly luring
> criminal minds.
>
> David Casillas, 13, also a member of MySpace.com and the
> church, said
> he’d tell his friends Tuesday — Monday is a holiday for him — that
> they should stop using MySpace. But he admitted that they’d
> “probably
> say no, because it’s like an addiction.”
>
> One parent of two teenagers, Lori Crabb, said parents should take
> advantage of the free filter software the church was handing
> out Sunday.
>
> “Until today, it was questionably safe,” she said. “But I now know
> fully the danger.”
>
> In contrast to the children who agreed with their pastor’s
> denunciation of MySpace, other young people in Bakersfield supported
> the popular Web site.
>
> MySpace.com users found on Chester Avenue in downtown Bakersfield
> Sunday afternoon had definite opinions about the Web site.
>
> “Where are the parents?” asked Alejandro Nuñez, 24, a local musician
> who has a 2-year-old son. He spends five hours a day on MySpace.com,
> he said, promoting his business and his band, using the site
> to build
> buzz and revenue.
>
> “Bad” is a subjective term, said Jonathan Pineda, 18, a MySpace.com
> user. Blaming MySpace.com for making pornography more available is
> senseless, he said — it’s everywhere.
>
> “People will find sin as easily as air,” he said.
>
> Valerie Ramirez, 27, has three kids and said she wouldn’t let her
> children use the site until they were 15 or 16. Until then,
> she said,
> her daughters “should be reading a book.”
>
> MySpace.com is so prevalent in the two years of its existence that
> Bakersfield College has outlawed the usage of MySpace.com on the
> college computers, according to a Feb. 1 story in The Renegade Rip,
> the college newspaper.
>
> But the dangers are becoming increasingly well-documented.
>
> As recently as Jan. 26, KHOU-TV in Houston, Texas, recounted
> the case
> of a 15-year-old girl who had sex with a 26-year-old man
> she’d met on
> MySpace.com.
>
> The last example proves that devious use of MySpace.com can have
> serious consequences.
>
> The pastor also blamed MySpace.com for fostering bisexuality and
> called the Internet “the devil’s biggest scheme he has ever inserted
> into our lives.”
>
> But part of Vietti’s message was intended to be shocking, he
> admitted. He expects to get phone calls and e-mails this week from
> some congregants regarding his sermon.
>
> “I think it’s worth saving one kid for all the e-mails and
> calls I’ll
> get,” Vietti said. “I want to make you moms and dads hopping
> mad,” he
> added.
>
>
> - - - - - - - - - - d a n a h ( d o t ) o r g - - - - - - - -
> - - "taken out of context i must seem so strange"
>
> musings :: http://www.zephoria.org/thoughts
>
>
>
> _______________________________________________
> The air-l at listserv.aoir.org mailing list
> is provided by the Association of Internet Researchers
> http://aoir.org Subscribe, change options or unsubscribe at:
> http://listserv.aoir.org/listinfo.cgi/air-l-aoir.org
>
> Join the Association of Internet Researchers:
> http://www.aoir.org/
>
More information about the Air-L
mailing list